Date: January 23rd, 2010 03:27 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] x3non.livejournal.com
However, there were First Amendment issues at stake (http://www.fixthefec.org/node/1129). Do you want our government to be banning books?


When the Supreme Court first heard the case last March, Deputy Solicitor General Malcolm L. Stewart, representing the FEC, was pulled into a discussion of an issue that brought him down a slippery slope: If the movie had been a book instead, would the government ban publishing the book if it mentioned a candidate for office within the election time frame?

Stewart said that it could.

"That's pretty incredible," said Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr.

Then came questions about electronic devices like the Kindle.

"If it has one name, one use of the candidate's name, it would be covered, correct?" asked Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr.

"That's correct," Stewart replied.

"It's a 500-page book, and at the end it says, 'And so vote for X,' the government could ban that?" Roberts asked again.

In retrospect, Bossie said, this was the moment that turned a majority of the bench against the FEC and in favor of Citizens United.

"That sent a chill down the Supreme Court," Bossie said. The argument became a "point of demarcation."

Profile

lunadelcorvo: (Default)
: : : L u n a d e l C o r v o : : :

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags

Miscellanea

InboxIcons
Customize

Things I need to remember:
• Asking for help is not, as it turns out, fatal.
• Laughing is easier than pulling your hair out, and doesn't have the unfortunate side effect of making you look like a plague victim.
• Even the biggest tasks can be defeated if taken a bit at a time.
• I can write a paper the night before it's due, but the results are not all they could be.
• Be thorough, but focused.
• Trust yourself.
• Honesty, always.

Historians are the Cassandras of the Humanities

Tags